Voting continues through December 31. Top vote recipients by position to date:
| Catcher (one to be selected) | Season(s) |
| 1. Johnny Edwards | 1960 |
| 2. Dutch Dotterer | 1957 |
| 3. Rube Novotney | 1952, 1953 |
| First Base (one to be selected) | Season(s) |
| 1. Jack Harshman | 1951 |
| 2. Chuck Coles | 1958 |
| 3. Jim Marshall | 1952 |
| 4. (tie) Larry DiPippo | 1954 |
| 4. (tie) Mel Corbo | 1963 |
| Second Base (one to be selected) | Season(s) |
| 1. Charlie Williams | 1955 |
| 2. (tie) Larry Taylor | 1956, 1957 |
| 2. (tie) Rod Kanehl | 1961 |
| Shortstop (one to be selected) | Season(s) |
| 1. Phil Sharzer | 1957, 1959, 1961 |
| 2. Bobby Durnbaugh | 1955, 1956, 1958 |
| 3. Billy Gardner | 1953 |
| 4. (tie) Daryl Spencer | 1951 |
| 4. (tie) Ziggy Jasinski | 1952 |
| 4. (tie) Alex Cosmodis | 1954 |
| 4. (tie) Bobby Henrich | 1960 |
| Third Base (one to be selected) | Season(s) |
| 1. Tommy “Buckshot” Brown | 1956, 1957 |
| 2. Rance Pless | 1952 |
| 3. Bob Boring | 1953 |
| 4. (tie) Bob Ludwig | 1950, 1951 |
| 4. (tie) Bob Meisner | 1961 |
| 6. Cliff Cook | 1960 |
| Outfield (three to be selected) | Season(s) |
| 1. Bob Lennon | 1953, 1954 |
| 2. Bama Ray | 1950, 1951, 1952 |
| 3. Stan Payls | 1957 |
| 4. Buddy Gilbert | 1958, 1959, 1960 |
| 5. Babe Barna | 1951 |
| 6. Bob Hazle | 1955 |
| 7. (tie) Tommy Neill | 1950, 1952 |
| 7. (tie) Eric Rodin | 1954 |
| 7. (tie) George Schmees | 1956, 1957 |
| 10. (tie) Harvey Gentry | 1953 |
| 10. (tie) Bill Taylor | 1953 |
| 10. (tie) Artie Dunham | 1954 |
| 10. (tie) Ben Downs | 1955 |
| 10. (tie) Ralph “Country” Brown | 1956 |
| 10. (tie) Chico Alvarez | 1959, 1960 |
| 10. (tie) Ev Joyner | 1961 |
| 10. (tie) Joe Christian | 1961 |
| Utility Player (one to be selected) | Season(s) |
| 1. Bob Boring | 1952 |
| 2. Buster Boguskie | 1954 |
| 3. Larry Taylor | 1955 |
| 4. (tie) Bill Werber | 1956 |
| 4. (tie) Rod Kanehl | 1960 |
| 6. (tie) Joe Damato | 1950, 1951 |
| 6. (tie) Jim Orton | 1963 |
| Left-handed Pitcher (two to be selected) | Season(s) |
| 1. Jim O’Toole | 1958 |
| 2. Bob Schultz | 1950, 1956 |
| 3. Roy Pardue | 1955, 1956, 1957 |
| 4. Jim Constable | 1952, 1953 |
| 5. Jim Bailey | 1958, 1959, 1960 |
| Right-hand Pitcher (Two to be selected) | Season(s) |
| 1. Jim Maloney | 1960 |
| 2. Jack Harshman | 1953 |
| 3. (tie) Al Worthington | 1952 |
| 3. (tie) Bob Kelly | 1956, 1957 |
| 5. Jay Hook | 1958 |
| 6. (tie) Jim Atchley | 1950, 1951 |
| 6. (tie) Pete Modica | 1951, 1952 |
| 6. (tie) Pete Mallory | 1951, 1952 |
| 6. (tie) Aubrey Gatewood | 1963 |
© 2024 by Skip Nipper. All Rights Reserved.
